We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post. This helps support what we do and in no way costs you a thing.
Pennsylvania is known for more than just Penn State and football Saturdays. Nestled among rolling hills and charming small towns Happy Valley, Pennsylvania, is a surprisingly diverse and downright delicious dining scene with a wide variety of must-try foodie finds. There’s a fun local saying here about the area being divided into “town and gown”—with “town” referring to the full-time residents, farmers, and small business owners, and “gown” referring to the students, faculty, and visiting families tied to the university.
This list of nine standout spots brings a little love from both sides. Whether you’re a local looking for a hidden gem or a visitor exploring campus, you’ll find a plethora of must-try foodie finds in Happy Valley, Pennsylvania, that are worth the detour.
1. Earlystown Diner
2770 Earlystown Rd, Centre Hall, PA
A true locals’ favorite, this cozy roadside diner serves hearty breakfasts and homestyle meals that feel like a warm hug. I came for the pancakes and eggs, but curiosity got the best of me—and I tried Scrapple for the first time.
What IS Scrapple?
If you’re not familiar, scrapple is a Pennsylvania Dutch favorite made from pork, cornmeal, and spices, then sliced and fried until crispy. Think of it as a savory breakfast slice with a soft interior and crunchy edges—comforting and hearty without overthinking it.
Crisped up just right and topped with maple syrup, it was savory, satisfying, and a little bit nostalgic. The Earlystown Diner is all about comfort food done right, with friendly service and that no-frills, small-town feel that makes you want to linger over your coffee.
2. Lionne at the Nittany Lion Inn
200 W Park Ave, State College, PA
Lionne is where elegance meets local flavor. Located inside the newly renovated Nittany Lion Inn, this fine-dining restaurant serves up seasonal, artistically plated dishes that look as stunning as they taste. From the amuse-bouche to the final course, every detail is thoughtfully curated.
It’s the perfect place for a celebratory meal, an upscale parents’ weekend dinner, or just a beautiful night out. The space is modern and intimate, and the service adds to the experience.
3. The Field Burger and Tap
1 Country Club Ln, State College, PA
Casual and cool, The Field Burger and Tap is popular with both students and visitors for its farm-to-fork burgers, house-made buns, and an extensive craft beer list. The burgers are massive—mine was almost the size of my head—and packed with juicy, flavorful beef sourced locally.
Don’t miss the monster milkshakes, topped with everything from donuts to popsicles. It’s the kind of place that’s buzzing with conversation, full of energy, and always leaves you full and happy.
4. Triplett’s at the Nittany Lion Inn
200 W Park Ave, State College, PA
Triplett’s offers a more casual experience than Lionne but still brings the flavor. With a focus on elevated comfort food, Triplett’s is a favorite among visiting families and hotel guests.
Their burgers are juicy and well-crafted, and the meatballs are a surprise standout—tender, well-seasoned, and perfect to share (or not!).
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or relaxing after a long day of sightseeing, Triplett’s delivers classic favorites in a refined setting.
5. The Federal Taphouse
130 S Fraser St Suite 200, State College, PA
Located in the heart of downtown, The Federal Taphouse is known for its street tacos, killer salads, and extensive beer list. It draws a lively mix of locals and students and is ideal for a night out or game-day dinner.
The tacos burst with flavor—think Korean BBQ, fish, and pulled pork options—and the salads are loaded with fresh, bold ingredients. Add a casual, upbeat atmosphere and this place becomes a go-to for group dinners and casual dates alike.
6. Faccia Luna
1229 South Atherton Street, State College, PA
This neighborhood trattoria is a local treasure for wood-fired pizzas, hearty pasta dishes, and homey Italian charm. It’s slightly off the student path, making it a favorite among residents looking for something familiar and comforting.
Don’t miss the Italian Wedding Soup, packed with tender meatballs and greens in a savory broth—it’s the perfect start to any meal. Faccia Luna is warm, welcoming, and reliably delicious.
7. Meyer Dairy Ice Cream
2390 S Atherton St, State College, PA
A nostalgic treat for locals and students alike, Meyer Dairy offers some of the creamiest, freshest ice cream in the region. This family-run creamery has been serving Happy Valley since 1887, and stepping inside feels like a trip back in time.
The portions are generous, the prices are fair, and the flavors range from classics to fun seasonal specials. It’s the kind of place where families stop after soccer practice, and students celebrate the end of finals with a double scoop.
8. Way Fruit Farm
2355 Halfmoon Valley Rd, Port Matilda, PA
Part orchard, part farm market, and part café, Way Fruit Farm is a year-round favorite—but it truly shines in the fall. The apple cider donuts are a must-try (especially warm), and their seasonal lattes make for a perfect pairing.
Browse the shop for local pantry staples, fresh produce, and handcrafted goodies while sipping your drink. It’s a scenic drive, and a beautiful stop to slow down and savor central PA flavor.
9. Goot Essa – Howard, PA
351 Wise Rd, Howard, PA
Nestled in the countryside, Goot Essa is your gateway to authentic Amish-made cheeses and jams. Known for high-quality, small-batch products made with traditional methods, their tasting room lets you sample everything before you buy.
The cheeses range from tangy and sharp to smooth and mild, and the jams are bursting with fruit-forward flavor. Goot Essa is ideal for those wanting to take a piece of Happy Valley home—or create a picnic that feels straight out of a storybook.
Final Thoughts on Must-Try Foodie Finds in Happy Valley, Pennsylvania
From farmhouse tables to elevated dining rooms, milkshakes to maple-drenched scrapple, Happy Valley, Pennsylvania is thriving with must-try foodie finds and serves up something for everyone—whether you’re team “town” or team “gown.” With a food scene this warm and varied, it’s easy to fall in love with central Pennsylvania one forkful at a time.
